| Top 40 Hits of September 1957 |
| 1 |
Paul Anka | Diana |
| 2 |
Pat Boone | Love Letters In The Sand |
| 3 |
Johnny Duncan & The Blue Grass Boys | Last Train To San Fernando |
| 4 |
Harry Belafonte | Island In The Sun |
| 5 |
Petula Clark | With All My Heart |
| 6 |
Tommy Steele | Water, Water / A Handful Of Songs |
| 7 |
Elvis Presley | All Shook Up |
| 8 |
Charlie Gracie | Wandering Eyes / I Love You So Much It Hurts |
| 9 |
Elvis Presley | Paralysed |
| 10 |
Debbie Reynolds | Tammy |
| 11 |
Elvis Presley | Teddy Bear |
| 12 |
Everly Brothers | Bye Bye Love |
| 13 |
Lonnie Donegan | Puttin' On The Style / Gamblin' Man |
| 14 |
Little Richard | Jenny Jenny |
| 15 |
Billy Ward & The Dominoes | Stardust |
| 16 |
Russ Hamilton | We Will Make Love |
| 17 |
Charlie Gracie | Fabulous |
| 18 |
Peter Sellers | Any Old Iron |
| 19 |
Johnnie Ray | Build Your Love |
| 20 |
King Brothers | In The Middle Of An Island |
| 21 |
Harry Belafonte | Scarlet Ribbons |
| 22 |
Diamonds | Little Darlin' |
| 23 |
Tommy Steele | Shiralee |
| 24 |
Crickets | That'll Be The Day |
| 25 |
Tony Brent | Dark Moon |
| 26 |
Larry Williams | Short Fat Fannie |
| 27 |
Billy Williams | I'm Gonna Sit Right Down And Write Myself A Letter |
| 28 |
Sal Mineo | Start Movin' (In My Direction) |
| 29 |
Ronnie Hilton | Around The World |
| 30 |
Pat Boone | Remember You're Mine / Gold Mine In The Sky |
| 31 |
Frankie Lymon & The Teenagers | Goody Goody |
| 32 |
Jerry Lee Lewis | Whole Lotta Shakin' Goin' On |
| 33 |
Charlie Gracie | I Love You So Much It Hurts |
| 34 |
Billy Eckstine & Sarah Vaughan | Passing Strangers |
| 35 |
Elvis Presley | Party |
| 36 |
Russ Hamilton | Wedding Ring |
| 37 |
Frankie Vaughan | Man On Fire / Wandering Eyes |
| 38 |
Shirley Bassey | You, You Romeo |
| 39 |
Various Artists | All-Star Hit Parade No 2 |
| 40 |
Tommy Steele | Butterfingers |
